(warning: shameless self plaigarism, I’m borrowing this book report from elsewhere… )
The Anarchist in the Library How the Clash Between Freedom and Control Is Hacking the Real World and Crashing the System
Siva Vaidhyanathan
A great survey of just what the subtitle says, “how the clash between freedom and control is hacking the real world and crashing the system.”
Earnest-as-fuck academic look at freedom on the innernets. Wish it had been written when I was in school, it would be a great reader in current topics from a left-liberal “information wants to be free” perspective. He reviews a number of different recent tech fights from the perspective of anarchy vs. oligarchy.
Criticisms would be:
- too close a focus on specific and current events means this book won’t age well – things are moving too fast for a book on issues like filesharing and DRM (hint: read his blog instead)
- I’d appreciate a bit more theory and a bit fewer specifics about this or that court battle.
- no charts? why no charts? Needs charts.
- for a book about anarchists and libraries, I was expecting a bit more sex.
Favourite part:
when my librarian gave the cover a double take and asked about it.
Comment / 07-06-2007 / 07:58 Q
Hi. Thanks so much for reading my book and posting about it. You are very generous in your comments and completely correct in your criticisms of it. It has not aged well.
Siva
Comment / 07-10-2007 / 06:23 Q
Jody, I hate to say it, but when you were in school, the Web didn’t exist.
Comment / 07-10-2007 / 06:48 Q
Oh, you mean university.
Leave a Reply
Powered by WordPress 3.0.4
Valid XHTML Strict?
Log in